Posted on

Electric Industry News, April 17, 2018

Today’s lede: Maine officials advocate steps to tamp down rising utility T&D costs. There is a roiling debate under way in Maine regarding rising electricity costs, and rising utility rates for transmission and distribution are a key factor, the state’s public advocate and a former director of Gov. Paul LePage’s energy office point out in the Bangor Daily News. See “Costly infrastructure is driving up Maine’s electricity costs”.

The economically troubling rising cost of electricity is “driven by more and more costly wires, poles and substations. This is a burden on Maine’s economy and households, and plans for further grid build-out at ratepayers’ expense keep coming, with [Central Maine Power] announcing a $214 million expansion for electricity infrastructure in Greater Portland in March,” observe Barry Hobbins and Ken Fletcher.

Hobbins is Maine’s public advocate and a former state legislator, where he co-chaired the Energy, Utilities and Technology Committee. Fletcher, a former executive in Maine’s paper industry and director of the governor’s energy office, is chairman of the board for the Efficiency Maine Trust. Fletcher also is a former Maine legislator with energy experience.

“Under state and federal regulations, monopoly utilities like CMP earn a guaranteed rate of return for spending ratepayer money on new wires and poles, creating a clear financial interest in making sure we have plenty of wires and poles to keep lights on but discouraging creative and cheaper alternatives to wires and poles,” the two write.

They fault Maine utility regulators for dragging their feet in implementing the Legislature’s 2009 smart grid framework and for “the rather stunning decision” last year to put the state’s utilities in charge of developing alternatives to wires infrastructure development.

They cited a pilot project in Boothbay Harbor where a $6 million investment in a combination of energy efficiency, distributed solar, storage and other alternatives to new wires was undertaken as an alternative to CMP’s proposal to build a new $18 million transmission line that would have cost consumers $75 million over the life of the transmission line. “There may be many more opportunities to capture this kind of savings, but they face big barriers, including those stemming from utilities’ financial interests,” Hobbins and Fletcher write.

“The electricity grid of the future won’t be — or shouldn’t be — the same as the grid of the past,” they write. “New and exciting technologies provide a powerful collection of alternatives to new wires, from the latest versions of well-known technologies like energy efficiency to rapidly emerging technologies like battery storage, distributed generation and sophisticated information tools to monitor and control demand for power. Many of these technologies give consumers more control and choice, and they can have a lower cost than new wires and poles.”

The two supported a formal recommendation by the commission’s professional staff to designate an independent coordinator to identify and propose lower cost alternatives to utility investments in transmission and distribution infrastructure. “[W]e should have an independent party with no financial interest in wires and poles to analyze and develop lower-cost alternatives to wires and poles.”

They called for amending LD 1487, An Act to Control Electricity Transmission Costs through the Development of Nontransmission Alternatives, now pending before the Energy, Utilities and Technology Committee, to establish such a “policy of independence and assign a group of stakeholders, including utilities and Efficiency Maine, to recommend how the details should work. This proposal would provide a bit more competition in an otherwise monopolistic arena.”

The issue is apparently not lost on state utility regulators, as evidenced by a passing comment made by Commissioner Carla Peterman of the California Public Utilities Commission during the recent National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners meeting in Washington, D.C. “As generation costs go down, we see transmission costs go up,” Peterman observed.

See also:

Central Maine Power responds to higher-than-average electricity bills

Answers can only be found through examining electricity use at each individual property


Viridity installs 1MW Johnson Controls battery at N.J. water treatment plant. Viridity Energy has installed a Johnson Controls one megawatt capacity battery at an Atlantic County Utilities Authority water treatment facility in New Jersey, Michelle Brunetti writes in the Press of Atlantic City. The electricity storage plant is being operated by Viridity under a 20-year agreement, and provides frequency regulation to the competitive wholesale power market operated by PJM Interconnection.

“Every two seconds we are putting in or taking out energy,” Viridity’s Paul Reed notes. “We respond to a signal PJM sends to operators.”

The battery augments the 7.5 megawatts of wind power and a 500-kilowatt photovoltaic solar field at the authority’s site, which altogether supply about 60 percent of the plant’s energy needs, Brunetti writes. “On the most energy-consuming days, usually the hottest, the battery will stop doing frequency regulation and start providing power to the wastewater treatment plant, so it can avoid paying the higher peak demand rates.” This offsets electricity demand the plant would otherwise take from the grid, Reed notes.



See also:

Ormat‘s Viridity to Begin Construction of 40MWh Energy Storage Systems in New Jersey

Energy Storage Systems Expected To Be Operational In Late 2018


Cape Cod official calls for more Massachusetts offshore wind development. Stable, responsible development of a wind power industry off the coast of Massachusetts that achieves the full potential requires developing multiple projects concurrently and accelerating the schedule for power purchase agreement solicitations, Cape Cod Chamber of Commerce CEO Wendy Northcross writes in The Barnstable Patriot.

More than 2,000 megawatts of new offshore wind development has been proposed by Vineyard Wind, Bay State Wind and Deepwater Wind in the Federal Wind Energy Area more than 14 miles south of Martha’s Vineyard was molded with community engagement that minimized fishing, recreation, transportation, viewsheds and environmental impacts, the commentary observes.

“By ensuring robust competition and diversity in the offshore wind industry from the start, the Commonwealth will pay decades worth of dividends into the state’s economy long after the first turbines are spinning,” Northcross writes.

See also:

New study finds that the market value of offshore wind varies significantly along the U.S. east coast


More news items of note:

Tesla Is Temporarily Shutting Down Model 3 Production. Again.

During the pause, workers can choose to use vacation days or stay home without pay. This is the second such temporary shutdown in three months for a vehicle that’s already significantly behind schedule.

Tesla production pause adds to Model 3 concerns

The Economic Impacts of the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative on Nine Northeast and Mid-Atlantic States

The Analysis Group’s Review of RGGI’s Third Three-Year Compliance Period (2015-2017)

The Yin and Yang of Bitcoin

Deregulation of U.S. power markets once made electricity the most volatile commodity in history. Could regulation be bitcoin’s yin to electricity’s yang?

Solar ownership still tilts towards high income, but evolving

An analysis of more than 800,000 solar installations has found that the median income of pv adopters is $32,000 per year higher than the median of all households, but the median income of buyers is on a downward trend.

ComEd Files for $23 Million Decrease in Customer Electric Rates in Illinois

Customer Reliability Improves by 50 Percent and the Average Residential Bill Remains Stable

Galesburg, Il., aldermen approve new contract for energy aggregation

Illinois town officials warn residents about electricity solicitors.

FERC rejects CAISO’s proposals to modify capacity procurement

California wildfire bill could lead to overspending, group warns

California bill aimed at wildfires effectively bans clean energy that may help prevent them

North Carolina approves solar rebate, coal ash fine for Duke

Boston shares RFI responses for municipal electricity aggregation program

Why Berkshire Hathaway’s utility is aiming for 100 percent renewable energy

Voltus Secures More Than 600 MWs of Demand Response in MISO for 2018

Up to $30,000/MW-Year Available for Customers

Most MISO zones clear capacity auction at $10/MW-day

The case for C&I storage investigated

Integrated Single Electricity Market delayed by IT issues

The start date for Ireland’s new single electricity market has been delayed for three months due to IT issues

Leave a Reply